Dongan Hills, Staten Island · Family owned · Since the early 2000s
Boiled, baked and built fresh daily—from first-light breakfast to stacked lunches and crowd-pleasing catering.
The neighborhood original
For over two decades, Not Just Bagels has served the Island with fresh bagels, specialty flavors, breakfast, lunch and homemade bakery favorites—all made with the care of a family-run shop.
Meet Not Just Bagels ↗
Made for real mornings
Start with the bagel. Pick your spread. Add eggs, cheese, bacon, sausage—or keep it classic. However you order, it’s prepared fresh.
Start your order↗
Not just breakfast. Not just bagels.
Easy, fresh Staten Island catering for home celebrations, school mornings, office parties and every gathering worth sharing.
Still family. Still fresh.
With the original owners back behind the business, Not Just Bagels is carrying forward the same warm, neighborhood spirit customers have known for decades—while making it easier to order, cater and share the food you love.
Voted Staten Island’s Best Bagel by the Daily News.
Locations we serve
Located in Dongan Hills, we offer delivery to nearby Staten Island neighborhoods—or come by for pickup and we’ll have your order ready.
Delivery availability may vary by address. Pickup is always easy at our Dongan Hills shop.
Before you order
Yes. Our bagels are boiled and baked fresh daily at our Dongan Hills shop. Breakfast sandwiches, deli sandwiches and other made-to-order favorites are prepared fresh when you order.
Yes. Delivery is available to nearby Staten Island neighborhoods. Enter your address on our online ordering page to confirm current availability, delivery timing and any order requirements for your location.
Absolutely. Order online, choose pickup, and we will prepare your order at our 1910 Hylan Boulevard shop. You can also call us at (718) 351-8870 with questions about a pickup order.
Yes. Our all-day breakfast menu is available during regular business hours, including fresh bagels, egg sandwiches, omelettes, pancakes and breakfast platters.
Yes. Choose from classic and specialty bagel flavors by the dozen, then add your favorite cream cheeses and spreads. Check the current menu or call for help planning a larger order.
We serve Dongan Hills and nearby areas including Grant City, New Dorp, Old Town, Midland Beach, South Beach, Grasmere, Todt Hill, Emerson Hill, Oakwood, Arrochar and Richmond Town. Exact availability depends on your address.
Yes. We cater home celebrations, school and team events, office parties, corporate breakfasts, birthdays, showers, holiday gatherings and community events throughout Staten Island.
Advance notice is recommended, especially for large groups, early morning delivery and weekend events. Call (718) 351-8870 so we can confirm timing, quantities and the best menu mix for your group.
Monday–Friday
5:30 AM–3 PM
Saturday–Sunday
6 AM–3 PM
